BHA Minutes
March 2001
Minutes of the BHA Board of Directors Meeting
March 21, 2001, Brickell Key One
Directors/Alternates
Present
Keith A. Reynolds, Cathy Coates/Brickell Key One
Herbert J. Bailey/Brickell Forest
Berdie
Archer/One Tequesta Point
Mac Seligman/Brickell
Townhouse
Florence Mazer/The Imperial
Yvonne Oppenheim/25 Bay Tower
Mark Steinberg,
Fred Ronen/Fortune House
Melvin F. Frankel,
Esq./Bristol Tower
Stoney Welsh, Mike
Glogower/The Palace
Paul Lewin/Brickell Bay
Club
Bruce Cotten/2000 Brickell
T. Sinclair (Tory) Jacobs/Brickell 25
Bryan
Hoffman/The Atlantis
Associate Member Present
Megan Kelly/Swire
Properties
Also Present
Sandra Frankel/Bristol Tower
Officer Jeffery
Giordano/Miami Police Dept., Coral Way NET
Kristin Read/Communications Plus
Daniel Leibow,
Joe Wilkins, Humberto Alonso, Debbie Swain/Miami
Roads Neighborhood Civic Assn.
Colin
Veeter/South Miami Avenue Homeowners Association
Gerald Marston/Wallace Rogers and Todd
Tony
Wagner/Coral Way NET Administrator
Harvey
Taylor, Scott Kramer, Jennifer Ciszczon, Andrew Singer/Taylor
Development & Land Company
Judith A. Burke,
Esq./Shutts & Bowen LLP
Bert
Leon/Revuelta-Vega-Leon Architects
Richard
Eichenger/Transport Analysis Professionals, Inc.
Mark Jacobsen/Taft Bradshaw Landscaping
The reading of the February minutes was
waived and they were approved with two corrections: 1) The City
Commission vote on 1900 Brickell Ave. was 3 to 2 against BHA
(not 4 to 1); and 2) the number of Brickell Bay Village project
parking spaces is 510.
Brickell Park.
The Save Brickell Park Committee reported that it does not appear
that the City Commission will take action to rescind the contract
with the Brickell family to sell the property and split the
proceeds.
Legal action is being
considered.
Graffiti.
Mac Seligman, Committee Chair, and Tony Wagner, NET Administrator,
reported on their investigation into how the City of Miami Beach
and also the Miami-Dade Transit Authority handle graffiti. Two
procedures emerged that will be investigated for use in Miami:
a strong chemical solvent and team of workers rather than one
or two. Mr. Wagner will report back on the tests.
Brickell Avenue Beautification.
Paul Lewin,
Committee Chair, assisted by Landscape
Architect
Jerry Marston presented the several approaches that
have been considered. At this point, the Committee has narrowed
their search to three themes, which are being developed. The
Committee will continue to report its progress to the Board.
1900 Brickell.
The Plastic Surgeon has asked BHA to support
his application to the City Commission for removal of the remaining
restrictions imposed when he was granted a Special Exception
including the prohibition against actually performing surgical
procedures on the site; in exchange, the plastic surgeon offered
to modify his offending signage and to install landscaping to
mitigate the starkness of the property and give it a lusher look
in keeping with its neighbors. The Board unanimously passed a
Resolution (attached and made a part of these Minutes) specifying
the terms required on his part for the BHA to grant his
request.
Commissioner Jimmy Morales' Cable TV
Town Meeting. Brickell Residents
are invited to call in or email questions and to tune in to this
program from 6:30 to 8:00 pm on March 27th.
Airplane Noise Abatement.
This scheduled
presentation was postponed until
the April
Meeting.
City
of Miami Police Department's Citizens'
Police
Academy Class #7. Brickell
Residents were invited to apply for participation in this 11-week
class starting March 29th, held from 6:00 to 10:00 pm with no
costs.
Condominium Living Course. Brickell Residents were invited to attend a free
four-hour program offered by the Center for Community &
Condominium
Living providing answers to the most
frequently asked questions
faced by Condo
Association Officers and Board Members. Course
to
be given on a Saturday morning at a Brickell facility.
Guard House on 25th Road @
Brickell. A
proposal to devote the funds allocated by the
Metropolitan for construction of a Guard House east of Brickell
on 25th Road to median and street-scape improvements was accepted
and made in the form of a Resolution to go to the City Commission.
The Resolution, passed unanimously, follows as a part of these
Minutes.
Brickell Way Village. Harvey Taylor, President of Taylor Land &
Development, along with his team, presented this mixed-use project
to be built east of the Brickell Publix, north of 15th Rd. It
will include residential, retail and office components. Mr.
Taylor invited suggestions and comments. Responses included:
plan landscaping in keeping with Simpson Park; coordinate
street-scapes,
landscaping, etc. with other
projects in the area. Concerns
were expressed
about the impact on traffic and possibly shadows
on
Simpson Park. Mr. Taylor agreed to take all of this into
consideration, rework his plans and come back to the Neighbors.
Brickell Bay
Village. The
Resolution passed at the February Meeting
opposed
to the granting a MUSP for this project as presently
constituted was formally read and unanimously passed and follows
as part of these Minutes.
Marlins Baseball Stadium. The Board Voted to draft a Resolution to go
to City, County and local State Legislators stating BHA'sopposition
to public funding of the Stadium and also to its Riverside location
unless and until traffic solutions are in place to prevent
stadium-generated
traffic from adding to the
already overburdened streets in the
Brickell, South
Miami Avenue and Roads Neighborhoods and also
in
the West Brickell Village neighborhood where several major
developments are in the works.
Next Meeting. 6:00 pm, Wed., April 18,
at the J.W. Marriott, 1111 Brickell Ave., London Room, 5th
floor.
Meeting adjourned at 7:50 pm.
Attachments: 3 Resolutions
RESOLUTION
BE IT HEREBY RESOLVED by Brickell Homeowners
Association that it opposes the Project under review for the
Brickell Bay Village Property located between the Bristol Tower
and Atlantis Condominiums in the 2100 Block of Brickell Avenue,
for the following reasons:
WHEREAS, the Project as designed imposes
an extreme burden on an already overtaxed roadway system, the
impact of which will be to reduce the quality of life of the
residents in the area, create additional traffic jams during
morning and late afternoon rush hours and cause hazardous conditions
to arise due to vehicles entering and leaving the Project which
enjoys a total of only 200 feet of frontage on Brickell Avenue
and only two curb cuts. In the absence of a traffic control device,
the only route for traffic exiting the property will be northbound
and for those heading South, a traffic-stopping U-Turn;
and
WHEREAS, the
project as conceived with
359 rental residential
units and 510 parking spaces with a maximum
of two
curb cuts within a 200-foot frontage will create a hazardous
condition for those residents needing to go south, who will be
forced to first head north, and then make a U-Turn to reverse
direction; and
WHEREAS, residents in rental units tend
to be in residence all year round, the impact or intensity of
use will be greater than a condominium of the same density, where
the owners in residence at any one time are generally less than
one finds in a rental apartment, and
WHEREAS, the design of the building and
its density on only 200 feet of frontage creates a negative impact
on the entire Brickell Corridor. It is the only building on Brickell
where so many units have been squeezed into only 200 feet of
frontage. The number of residents in such a building, their vehicles
and the traffic created, impose a significantly greater burden
(intensity of use) than any other building in the area;
and
WHEREAS, the
resulting negative impact
on the quality of life
for the residents of the area will negatively
impact the City of Miami from an economic standpoint. Brickell
Avenue right now offers the City its highest ad valorem tax base.
A building such as this, which aggressively uses the property
for a greater density and impact than others in the neighborhood,
will negatively impact property valuesin the area due to a decline
in the quality of life caused by the traffic degradation, crowding
and congestion, all of which are key elements in causing a drop
in demand for properties in the area, and the consequentially
lower property values.
NOW THEREFORE, for all of the foregoing
reasons, be it hereby
RESOLVED, that the Brickell Avenue Homeowners
Association go on record in opposition to the pending application
for approval of a Special Use Permit and urges all Departments
of the City of Miami and the Miami City Commission to reject
the application of Applicant for a Special Use Permit for
construction
of 359 residential units and 510
parking spaces; and be it
FURTHER RESOLVED, that a true and correct
copy of this Resolution be presented to the City Commission of
the City of Miami at the Public Hearing to be held to consider
the application of the Developer on March 29, 2001.
Signed and executed on behalf of the Board
of Directors of Brickell Homeowners Association on this 21st
day of March 2001, at Miami, Miami-Dade County, Florida.
Signed: T. Sinclair (Tory) Jacobs,
President
Attested: Mac Seligman,
Secretary
RESOLUTION
BE IT HEREBY RESOLVED by Brickell Homeowners
Association that it requests the City of Miami Commission modify
its condition of the MUSP for the Metropolitan to substitute
a cash payment to the City of Miami of $50,000 to a like amount
in SE 25th Road median improvements.
WHEREAS, the MUSP for the Metropolitan
Project required a contribution toward the construction of a
guard gate in the amount of $50,000; and
WHEREAS, that requirement was conditioned
upon securing the approval of the adjoining neighbors within
a certain time and failing that approval the money was to be
paid to City of Miami; and
WHEREAS, the approval of the neighbors
was not secured and it is the desire of the neighbors and the
developer to make landscape improvements to the median adjacent
to the neighbors and the development in the amount of
$50,000.
Now,
therefore, be it resolved by the
Brickell
Homeowners Association that the City of Miami is requested
to modify its MUSP requirements for the Metropolitan to reflect
that the $50,000 is not paid to the City of Miami but is instead
used to make median improvements to SE 25th Road adjacent to
the project.
FURTHER RESOLVED, that a true and correct
copy of this Resolution be presented to the City Commission of
the City of Miami at the Public Hearing to be held to consider
the application of the Developer on April 26, 2001.
Signed and executed on behalf of the Board
of Directors of Brickell Homeowners Association on this _____
day of April 2001, at Miami, Miami-Dade County, Florida.
Signed: T. Sinclair (Tory) Jacobs,
President
Attested: Mac Seligman,
Secretary
RESOLUTION
BE IT HEREBY RESOLVED by Brickell Homeowners
Association that it will support Dr. Jorge Suarez-Menendez's
petition before the Miami City Commission to remove the current
prohibition against conducting plastic surgical procedures and
other restrictions currently part of the Special Exception
Resolution
except the overnight stay provision
which will continue at 1900
Brickell Avenue
provided the landscaping designs presented by
Wallace Roberts & Todd are implemented to the sign-off approval
of Gerald Marston, principal of Wallace Roberts & Todd prior
to the City Commission hearing for the requested change.
And provided that the only exterior sign
on the property be of a professional appearance limited
to:
Jorge
Suarez-Menendez, MD
Plastic
Surgeon
Provided
further that there will be no
subsequent material
changes in the signage and landscaping without
Wallace Roberts Todd approval (prior and post) as long as Dr.
Suarez-Menendez practices at this location.
FURTHER RESOLVED, that a true and correct
copy of this Resolution be presented to the City Commission of
the City of Miami at the Public Hearing to be held to consider
the petition of Dr. Suarez-Menendez on
__________________.
Signed and executed on behalf of the Board
of Directors of Brickell Homeowners Association on this _____
day of ________ 2001, at Miami, Miami-Dade County,
Florida.
Signed:
T. Sinclair (Tory) Jacobs, President
Attested:
Mac Seligman, Secretary
|